Alfano's Pizza Restaurant

Enjoy delicious handcrafted pizzas, pasta, and desserts at Alfano's Pizza Restaurant in Carthage, IL. Savor deep dish, gluten-free options, and flavorful classics like chicken alfredo and cannolis. Call us today!

Welcome to Alfano's Pizza Restaurant

Taste the Difference.

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant serves up delicious, homemade food in the heart of Carthage, Illinois. With a prime location at 93 S Adams St, this charming eatery draws in both locals and visitors. It’s known for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu, featuring everything from deep dish pizza to gluten-free options. More than just pizza, you’ll find pasta, sandwiches, and tempting desserts.

Whether dining in with friends or grabbing takeout for a family night, Alfano's promises a satisfying meal. The smell of fresh-baked pizza greets you at the door, inviting you to indulge in Italian favorites.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

93 S Adams St, Carthage, IL 62321, United States

Phone

+1 217-357-9951

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant
Alfano's Pizza Restaurant

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant has been a staple in Carthage, Illinois, serving the community with authentic Italian cuisine. Established years ago, it quickly earned a reputation for quality and flavor. Each dish reflects a passion for cooking, using fresh ingredients sourced from local vendors whenever possible. The friendly staff creates a welcoming environment, making each guest feel like family. This restaurant isn’t just a dining establishment; it’s a community hub where memories are made over hearty meals.

The menu features 71 distinct items, providing ample choices for everyone, whether you crave appetizers, salads, or filled pasta dishes.

Among its offerings, the pasta dinners remain a crowd favorite, especially the homemade lasagna and fettuccine alfredo. Alfano's also caters to younger guests with a special kids menu, ensuring that even the littlest diners have something tasty to enjoy. Value shines through with affordable prices, averaging just $5.32 per dish. Beer and wine selections add to the dining experience, allowing patrons to pair their meals perfectly.

Local traditions thrive here; on busy weekends, families fill the place, celebrating life’s moments.

It’s common to see groups sharing large pizzas and reminiscing about past visits. The combination of great food and community spirit makes Alfano’s more than just a restaurant; it embodies the heart of Carthage.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-2 PM 4-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-2 PM 4-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-2 PM 4-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-2 PM 4-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-2 PM 4-9 PM

Alfano's boasts an extensive menu, appealing to every palate. Popular dishes include delicious pasta alfredo and chicken alfredo, which are creamy and comforting. The deep dish pizza stands out with its rich, thick crust, making it a local favorite. Don't overlook the gluten-free and taco pizza options for those with dietary needs. Enjoy decadent desserts like homemade cannoli and tiramisu that offer a sweet finish to any meal. The restaurant provides a cozy setting ideal for gatherings. It thrives during peak times, particularly on Saturdays at 5 PM, showcasing its value in the community.

Alfano's Pizza Restaurant

The exterior of Alfano's Pizza Restaurant displays a classic charm, blending seamlessly with its surroundings on S Adams St. The inviting signage and warm lighting create a welcoming entrance, drawing visitors in. The outdoor seating area offers a pleasant option for enjoying meals during warm weather, making it a favored spot for casual lunches and dinners. The restaurant's vibe reflects a mix of family-friendly casual dining and a bustling community atmosphere, perfect for gathering friends and family.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

We felt like Italian, so we found this little gem nestled in Carthage's town square, so we thought we'd try it out. Historic brick bldg, comfortable vibes, everyone was so friendly and smiley. We ordered an XL Canadian Bacon, Bacon Pizza, Garlic Cheesy Bread, and a side salad. We wanted to take some home as well, which we had plenty of leftovers for later. We were there around 1pm, lunch rush maybe. Plenty of seating. Outdoor seating available too. The food was delivered in a timely manner. Hot, fresh, delicious! The husband loved the Sweet Tea too. Even when groups started piling in, we were never left alone to long by our server/waitress. The restrooms were clean and fully stocked! Cute photo op corners. It was my first time at a Alfano's within our area. Not sure if all of them are privately owned or not. Thank you for such a wonderful first experience! Hit all my marks for a 5 Review!

M
Maureen V.

We stopped here on our way through town. The food was amazing and the prices were better! We got a little bit of random things to try. Chicago style pizza, ravioli and subs. Our total was under $40. We will definitely stop back in the next time we come by!

K
Katrina F.

1st time eating there. The place was very busy. The food was great, I had the large Philly cheese steak, and my wife had the Chicken Alfredo. The main thing I saw people eating was the pizzas. That's definitely what I want to try next.

J
Jack S.

Wonderful Italian restaurant on the historic Carthage square. I've been there several times over the years and they have never disappointed. Always kind staff and quick service to boot. I had their very delicious Italian sub. In the past I have enjoyed their thin delicious crust Pizza. They get a thumbs up for me. Update. In addition I just enjoy their taco pizza. Lots of fresh toppings, crisp lettuce, and crunchy chips. Overall this is an excellent taco pizza!

D
Dan M.

We went on a Friday evening on our way thru town. It was clean and the waitress was friendly, fast and efficient. Will go again.

T
Tracie H.

Very good food. Fair price. It comes out quickly and everything we tried was great.

J
John S.